I am with the developers on this, the core of Joomla! should continue to be licenced under the GPL. However, I wonder whether the interfaces that are exposed to the developers of external components could use the LGPL?
This is effectively what happens with something like the GNU C compiler and the associated glibc library.
Mixed licencing
*IF* you want to share your opinion on the GPL issue, this is the place for you.
- epeeist
- Joomla! Intern
- Posts: 53
- Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2005 7:28 pm
- Location: Manchester, UK
- Jinx
- Joomla! Champion
- Posts: 6508
- Joined: Fri Aug 12, 2005 12:47 am
- Contact:
Re: Mixed licencing
Post by Jinx » Sat Jun 23, 2007 2:35 pm
That would indeed be a possible option. For Joomla! 1.5 we have tried to achieve this by removing any none-LGPL external libraries, replacing them or recoding them in our own Joomla! framework. We have also requested developers to contribute their code for use in the framework under the LGPL license, this will allow OSM to license the framework under LGPL in the future if they would like to do so.
At the moment there is one major problem with this approach. There is still not enough clear seperation bewteen the framework part (the API's) and the CMS (Joomla!). While we tried, we have failed to achieve enough de-coupling between both for Joomla! 1.5. Our goal is to improve de-coupling in future releases and have a very clearly seperated framework, that hopefully for Joomla! 2.0 could be licensed as LGPL.
We are trying, we are just not there yet.
Johan
Note : made smaller changes to text
At the moment there is one major problem with this approach. There is still not enough clear seperation bewteen the framework part (the API's) and the CMS (Joomla!). While we tried, we have failed to achieve enough de-coupling between both for Joomla! 1.5. Our goal is to improve de-coupling in future releases and have a very clearly seperated framework, that hopefully for Joomla! 2.0 could be licensed as LGPL.
We are trying, we are just not there yet.
Johan
Note : made smaller changes to text
Last edited by Jinx on Sat Jun 23, 2007 10:56 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Johan Janssens - Joomla Co-Founder, Lead Developer of Joomla 1.5
http://www.joomlatools.com - Joomla extensions that just work
http://www.joomlatools.com - Joomla extensions that just work
- severdia
- Joomla! Guru
- Posts: 531
- Joined: Mon May 01, 2006 4:34 pm
- Contact:
Re: Mixed licencing
Post by severdia » Tue Jun 26, 2007 1:44 am
So is this a message to 3PDs wanting to maintain their development model to hold out on Joomla until v2 when a LGPL will allow them lower-level access?
Author | Speaker | Mad Scientist
Author of Using Joomla from O'Reilly Media | http://www.usingjoomlabook.com/
Shakespeare and Joomla | http://www.playshakespeare.com
Author of Using Joomla from O'Reilly Media | http://www.usingjoomlabook.com/
Shakespeare and Joomla | http://www.playshakespeare.com
- louis.landry
- Joomla! Ace
- Posts: 1380
- Joined: Wed Aug 17, 2005 11:03 pm
- Location: San Jose, California
- Contact:
Re: Mixed licencing
Post by louis.landry » Tue Jun 26, 2007 2:07 am
No, it is not.
http://forum.joomla.org/index.php/topic ... #msg877340
It is not a veiled message, just a statement of intent and vision that we have had.
Just because a part of a GPL application is LGPL does mean interfacing with the LGPL changes the game. The code is still part of the greater compiled and executed application which is GPL.
The purpose of making the libraries LGPL is not to change anything about the Joomla! CMS but allow the libraries/framework to live standalone in another context.
Louis
http://forum.joomla.org/index.php/topic ... #msg877340
It is not a veiled message, just a statement of intent and vision that we have had.
Just because a part of a GPL application is LGPL does mean interfacing with the LGPL changes the game. The code is still part of the greater compiled and executed application which is GPL.
The purpose of making the libraries LGPL is not to change anything about the Joomla! CMS but allow the libraries/framework to live standalone in another context.
Louis
Joomla Platform Maintainer
A hacker does for love what others would not do for money.
A hacker does for love what others would not do for money.
- severdia
- Joomla! Guru
- Posts: 531
- Joined: Mon May 01, 2006 4:34 pm
- Contact:
Re: Mixed licencing
Post by severdia » Tue Jun 26, 2007 2:54 am
Ah...thanks for the clarification!
Author | Speaker | Mad Scientist
Author of Using Joomla from O'Reilly Media | http://www.usingjoomlabook.com/
Shakespeare and Joomla | http://www.playshakespeare.com
Author of Using Joomla from O'Reilly Media | http://www.usingjoomlabook.com/
Shakespeare and Joomla | http://www.playshakespeare.com
Jump to
- Joomla! Announcements
- ↳ Announcements
- ↳ Announcements Discussions
- Joomla! 5.x - Ask Support Questions Here
- ↳ General Questions/New to Joomla! 5.x
- ↳ Installation Joomla! 5.x
- ↳ Administration Joomla! 5.x
- ↳ Migrating and Upgrading to Joomla! 5.x
- ↳ Security in Joomla! 5.x
- ↳ Extensions for Joomla! 5.x
- ↳ Templates for Joomla! 5.x
- ↳ Search Engine Optimization (Joomla! SEO) in Joomla! 5.x
- ↳ Language - Joomla! 5.x
- ↳ Performance - Joomla! 5.x
- ↳ Joomla! 5.x Coding
- Joomla! 4.x - Ask Support Questions Here
- ↳ General Questions/New to Joomla! 4.x
- ↳ Installation Joomla! 4.x
- ↳ Administration Joomla! 4.x
- ↳ Migrating and Upgrading to Joomla! 4.x
- ↳ Extensions for Joomla! 4.x
- ↳ Security in Joomla! 4.x
- ↳ Templates for Joomla! 4.x
- ↳ Search Engine Optimization (Joomla! SEO) in Joomla! 4.x
- ↳ Language - Joomla! 4.x
- ↳ Performance - Joomla! 4.x
- ↳ Joomla! 4.x Coding
- Joomla! Versions which are End of Life
- ↳ Joomla! 3.x - End of Life 17 Aug 2023
- ↳ General Questions/New to Joomla! 3.x
- ↳ Installation Joomla! 3.x
- ↳ Joomla! 3.x on IIS webserver
- ↳ Administration Joomla! 3.x
- ↳ Access Control List (ACL) in Joomla! 3.x
- ↳ Migrating and Upgrading to Joomla! 3.x
- ↳ Security in Joomla! 3.x
- ↳ Extensions for Joomla! 3.x
- ↳ Templates for Joomla! 3.x
- ↳ Search Engine Optimization (Joomla! SEO) in Joomla! 3.x
- ↳ Language - Joomla! 3.x
- ↳ Performance - Joomla! 3.x
- ↳ Joomla! 3.x Coding
- ↳ Joomla! 2.5 - End of Life 31 Dec 2014
- ↳ General Questions/New to Joomla! 2.5
- ↳ Installation Joomla! 2.5
- ↳ Joomla! 2.5 on IIS webserver
- ↳ Administration Joomla! 2.5
- ↳ Access Control List (ACL) in Joomla! 2.5
- ↳ Migrating and Upgrading to Joomla! 2.5
- ↳ Security in Joomla! 2.5
- ↳ Extensions for Joomla! 2.5
- ↳ Templates for Joomla! 2.5
- ↳ Search Engine Optimization (Joomla! SEO) in Joomla! 2.5
- ↳ Language - Joomla! 2.5
- ↳ Performance - Joomla! 2.5
- ↳ Joomla! 1.5 - End of Life Sep 2012
- ↳ General Questions/New to Joomla! 1.5
- ↳ Installation 1.5
- ↳ Joomla! 1.5 on IIS webserver
- ↳ Administration 1.5
- ↳ Migrating and Upgrading to Joomla! 1.5
- ↳ Security in Joomla! 1.5
- ↳ Extensions for Joomla! 1.5
- ↳ Templates for Joomla! 1.5
- ↳ Search Engine Optimization (Joomla! SEO) in Joomla! 1.5
- ↳ Language - Joomla! 1.5
- ↳ Performance - Joomla! 1.5
- ↳ Joomla! 1.0 - End of Life 22 July 2009
- ↳ Installation - 1.0.x
- ↳ Upgrading - 1.0.x
- ↳ Security - 1.0.x
- ↳ 3rd Party/Non Joomla! Security Issues
- ↳ Administration - 1.0.x
- ↳ Extensions - 1.0.x
- ↳ Components
- ↳ Modules
- ↳ Plugins/Mambots
- ↳ WYSIWYG Editors - 1.0.x
- ↳ Integration & Bridges - 1.0.x
- ↳ phpbb - Joomla! Integration
- ↳ Templates & CSS - 1.0.x
- ↳ Language - 1.0.x
- ↳ Joom!Fish and Multilingual Sites
- ↳ Performance - 1.0.x
- ↳ General Questions - 1.0.x
- Joomla! International Language Support
- ↳ International Zone
- ↳ Arabic Forum
- ↳ تنبيهات هامة
- ↳ الدروس
- ↳ 5.x جوملا!
- ↳ 4.x جوملا!
- ↳ جوملا! 1.6/1.7
- ↳ الأسئلة الشائعة
- ↳ التثبيت و الترقية
- ↳ الحماية - و تحسين السرعة والأداء
- ↳ لوحة التحكم
- ↳ الإضافات البرمجية
- ↳ تعريب جوملا! و الإضافات البرمجية
- ↳ القوالب و التصميم
- ↳ صداقة محركات البحث
- ↳ القسم العام
- ↳ 1.5 !جوملا
- ↳ الأسئلة الشائعة
- ↳ التثبيت و الترقية
- ↳ الحماية - و تحسين السرعة والأداء
- ↳ لوحة التحكم
- ↳ الإضافات البرمجية
- ↳ تعريب جوملا! و الإضافات البرمجية
- ↳ القوالب و التصميم
- ↳ صداقة محركات البحث
- ↳ القسم العام
- ↳ جوملا! 1.0
- ↳ الأسئلة الشائـعة
- ↳ التثبيت
- ↳ لوحة التحكم
- ↳ الإضافات البرمجية
- ↳ الإضافات المعرّبة
- ↳ القوالب و التصميم
- ↳ الحماية - تحسين السرعة والأداء - صداقة محركات البحث
- ↳ القسم العام
- ↳ القسم العام
- ↳ !عرض موقعك بجوملا
- ↳ الأرشيف
- ↳ Bengali Forum
- ↳ Bosnian Forum
- ↳ Joomla! 1.5
- ↳ Instalacija i prvi koraci
- ↳ Ekstenzije
- ↳ Templejti
- ↳ Moduli
- ↳ Prevodi i dokumentacija
- ↳ Joomla! 1.7 / Joomla! 1.6
- ↳ Catalan Forum
- ↳ Notícies
- ↳ Temes sobre l'administració
- ↳ Temes sobre la traducció
- ↳ Components, mòduls i joombots
- ↳ Temes de disseny
- ↳ Webs realitzades amb Joomla!
- ↳ Offtopics
- ↳ Chinese Forum
- ↳ Croatian Forum
- ↳ Danish Forum
- ↳ Meddelelser
- ↳ Joomla! 5.x
- ↳ Joomla! 4.x
- ↳ Joomla! 3.x (Anbefalet til nye installationer. Nyeste funktionalitet)
- ↳ Installation, backup, opdatering og flytning - Godt igang
- ↳ Administration - Generel brug
- ↳ Komponenter, Moduler og Plugins
- ↳ Template, CSS og Design
- ↳ Nethandel, betaling m.m.
- ↳ Ældre versioner (disse vedligeholdes ikke længere fra officiel side)
- ↳ Joomla! 2.5 (Supporteres indtil 31. dec. 2014)
- ↳ Installation, backup, opdatering og flytning - Godt igang
- ↳ Administration - Generel brug
- ↳ Komponenter, Moduler og Plugins
- ↳ Template, CSS og Design
- ↳ Nethandel, betaling m.m.
- ↳ Joomla 1.5 (Tidligere langtidssupporteret version indtil sep. 2012)
- ↳ Installation, backup, opdatering og flytning - Godt igang
- ↳ Administration - Generel brug
- ↳ Komponenter, Moduler og Plugins
- ↳ Template, CSS og Design
- ↳ Nethandel, betaling m.m.
- ↳ Joomla 1.0 (Udgået version, der blev afløst af 1.5 i 2008)
- ↳ Installation, backup, opdatering og flytning - Godt igang
- ↳ Administration - Generel brug
- ↳ Komponenter, Moduler og Mambots
- ↳ Template, CSS og Design
- ↳ Nethandel, betaling m.m.
- ↳ Oversættelser (lokalisering)
- ↳ Joomla brugergrupper i Danmark
- ↳ JUG Kolding
- ↳ JUG København
- ↳ JUG Odense
- ↳ JUG Århus
- ↳ JUG Sorø
- ↳ Kommerciel (betalt) hjælp ønskes
- ↳ SEO
- ↳ FAQ - Dokumentation og vejledninger
- ↳ Vis dit websted
- ↳ Afviste 'Vis dit websted' indlæg
- ↳ Diverse (Off topic)
- ↳ Dutch Forum
- ↳ Aankondigingen
- ↳ Algemene vragen
- ↳ Joomla! 5.x
- ↳ Joomla! 4.x
- ↳ Joomla! 3.x
- ↳ Installatie 3.x
- ↳ Extensies 3.x
- ↳ Templates 3.x
- ↳ Joomla! 2.5
- ↳ Installatie 2.5
- ↳ Componenten 2.5
- ↳ Modules 2.5
- ↳ Plugins 2.5
- ↳ Templates 2.5
- ↳ Joomla! 1.5
- ↳ Installatie
- ↳ Componenten
- ↳ Modules
- ↳ Plugins
- ↳ Templates
- ↳ Joomla! 1.0
- ↳ Installatie 1.0.x
- ↳ Componenten 1.0.x
- ↳ Modules 1.0.x
- ↳ Mambots 1.0.x
- ↳ Templates 1.0.x
- ↳ Vertalingen
- ↳ Offtopic
- ↳ Show jouw website
- ↳ Filipino Forum
- ↳ International Support Center
- ↳ Pinoy General Discussion & Archives
- ↳ Site Showcase
- ↳ Events
- ↳ Design Tips and Tricks
- ↳ Tsismis Zone
- ↳ Pinoy Translation Zone
- ↳ Pinoy Forum Archives
- ↳ Joomla! Philippines Local Forum www.joomla.org.ph
- ↳ Finnish Forum
- ↳ French Forum
- ↳ Les annonces!
- ↳ Le bistrot!
- ↳ L'expo!
- ↳ J! 5.x - L'atelier!
- ↳ J! 4.x - L'atelier!
- ↳ J! 3.x - L'atelier!
- ↳ 3.x - Questions générales, nouvel utilisateur
- ↳ 3.x - Installation, migration et mise à jour
- ↳ 3.x - Sécurité et performances
- ↳ 3.x - Extensions tierce partie
- ↳ 3.x - Templates et design
- ↳ 3.x - Développement
- ↳ 3.x - Ressources
- ↳ J! 2.5.x - L'atelier!
- ↳ 2.5 - Questions générales
- ↳ 2.5 - Installation, migration et mise à jour
- ↳ 2.5 - Sécurité et performances
- ↳ 2.5 - Extensions tierce partie
- ↳ 2.5 - Templates et design
- ↳ 2.5 - Développement
- ↳ 2.5 - Ressources
- ↳ J! 1.5.x - L'atelier!
- ↳ 1.5 - Questions générales
- ↳ 1.5 - Installation, migration et mise à jour
- ↳ 1.5 - Sécurité et performances
- ↳ 1.5 - Extensions tierce partie
- ↳ 1.5 - Templates et design
- ↳ 1.5 - Développement
- ↳ 1.5 - Ressources
- ↳ J! 1.0.x - L'atelier!
- ↳ 1.0 - Questions générales
- ↳ 1.0 - Installation et mise à jour
- ↳ 1.0 - Sécurité
- ↳ 1.0 - Extensions tierce partie
- ↳ 1.0 - Templates et design
- ↳ 1.0 - Développement
- ↳ 1.0 - Ressources
- ↳ Besoin d'un professionel ?
- ↳ Extensions Open Source pour Joomla!
- ↳ German Forum
- ↳ Ankündigungen
- ↳ Joomla! 5.x
- ↳ Joomla! 4.x
- ↳ Joomla! 3.x
- ↳ Allgemeine Fragen
- ↳ Installation und erste Schritte
- ↳ Komponenten, Module, Plugins
- ↳ Template, CSS und Designfragen
- ↳ Entwicklerforum
- ↳ Zeige Deine Webseite
- ↳ Joomla! 2.5
- ↳ Allgemeine Fragen
- ↳ Installation und erste Schritte
- ↳ Komponenten, Module, Plugins
- ↳ Template, CSS und Designfragen
- ↳ Entwicklerforum
- ↳ Zeige Deine Webseite
- ↳ Joomla! 1.5
- ↳ Allgemeine Fragen
- ↳ Installation und erste Schritte
- ↳ Komponenten, Module, Plugins
- ↳ Template, CSS und Designfragen
- ↳ Entwicklerforum
- ↳ Zeige Deine Webseite
- ↳ Professioneller Service
- ↳ Sonstiges (Offtopic)
- ↳ Archiv
- ↳ Joomla! 1.0
- ↳ Allgemeine Fragen 1.0.x
- ↳ Installation und erste Schritte 1.0.x
- ↳ Komponenten, Module, Mambots 1.0.x
- ↳ Template, CSS und Designfragen 1.0.x
- ↳ Entwicklerforum 1.0.x
- ↳ Zeige Deine Webseite 1.0.x
- ↳ Greek Forum
- ↳ Joomla! 4.x
- ↳ Joomla! 3.x
- ↳ Joomla! 2.5.x
- ↳ Joomla! 1.5.x
- ↳ Joomla! 1.0.x
- ↳ Hebrew Forum
- ↳ Indic Languages Forum
- ↳ Indonesian Forum
- ↳ FAQ
- ↳ Bantuan
- ↳ Komponen
- ↳ Modul
- ↳ Template
- ↳ Diskusi
- ↳ Italian Forum
- ↳ Guide
- ↳ Traduzioni
- ↳ Componenti - Moduli - Plugins
- ↳ Template - Grafica
- ↳ Notizie
- ↳ Prodotti Open Source per Joomla!
- ↳ Richieste professionali
- ↳ Joomla! 5.x
- ↳ Joomla! 4.x
- ↳ Joomla! 3.x
- ↳ Joomla! 2.5.x
- ↳ Joomla! 1.x
- ↳ Latvian Forum
- ↳ Lithuanian Forum
- ↳ Joomla! 5.x
- ↳ Joomla! 4.x
- ↳ Joomla! 1.7 / Joomla! 1.6
- ↳ Joomla! 1.5
- ↳ Joomla! 1.0
- ↳ Vertimai ir Kalba
- ↳ Malaysian Forum
- ↳ Solved
- ↳ Norwegian Forum
- ↳ Informasjon
- ↳ Arkiverte annonseringer
- ↳ FAQ - Ofte spurte spørsmål
- ↳ Arkiv
- ↳ Joomla! 5.x
- ↳ Joomla! 4.x
- ↳ Joomla! 3.x
- ↳ Administrasjon/installasjon
- ↳ Migrering/Oppdatering
- ↳ Template, CSS og design
- ↳ Komponenter/moduler/programutvidelser
- ↳ Sikkerhet
- ↳ Generelt
- ↳ Netthandel, betaling m.m.
- ↳ VirtueMart
- ↳ Andre nettbutikkløsninger
- ↳ Generelt
- ↳ Oversettelser
- ↳ Fremvisning av sider (Show off)
- ↳ Avviste fremvisninger
- ↳ Diverse (off topic)
- ↳ Kommersiell hjelp ønskes
- ↳ Eldre versjoner av Joomla!
- ↳ Joomla! 1.0
- ↳ Administrasjon/installasjon
- ↳ Template, CSS og design
- ↳ Komponenter/moduler/mambots
- ↳ Sikkerhet
- ↳ Generelt
- ↳ Joomla! 1.5
- ↳ Administrasjon/installasjon
- ↳ Migrering/Oppdatering
- ↳ Template, CSS og design
- ↳ Komponenter/moduler/programutvidelser
- ↳ Sikkerhet
- ↳ Generelt
- ↳ Joomla! 2.5
- ↳ Administrasjon/installasjon
- ↳ Migrering/Oppdatering
- ↳ Template, CSS og design
- ↳ Komponenter/moduler/programutvidelser
- ↳ Sikkerhet
- ↳ Generelt
- ↳ Persian Forum
- ↳ قالب ها
- ↳ مدیریت
- ↳ سوالهای عمومی
- ↳ نصب
- ↳ مامبوت ها
- ↳ ماژولها
- ↳ کامپوننت ها
- ↳ Polish Forum
- ↳ Instalacja i aktualizacja
- ↳ Administracja
- ↳ Komponenty, moduły, wtyczki
- ↳ Szablony
- ↳ Paczta i Podziwiajta
- ↳ Modyfikacje i własne rozwiązania
- ↳ Tłumaczenia
- ↳ FAQ
- ↳ Tips&Tricks
- ↳ Dokumentacja
- ↳ Profesjonalne usługi
- ↳ Portuguese Forum
- ↳ Componentes, módulos e mambots
- ↳ Programação e desenvolvimento
- ↳ Segurança
- ↳ Sites dos usuários
- ↳ Off-topic
- ↳ Tradução
- ↳ Templates
- ↳ Romanian Forum
- ↳ Traduceri
- ↳ Russian Forum
- ↳ Объявления по Joomla!
- ↳ Безопасность Joomla!
- ↳ Joomla 5.x - Задайте здесь свой вопрос по поддержке
- ↳ Joomla 4.x - Задайте здесь свой вопрос по поддержке
- ↳ Joomla 3.x - Задайте здесь свой вопрос по поддержке
- ↳ Общие вопросы/Новичок в Joomla! 3.x
- ↳ Установка Joomla! 3.x
- ↳ Миграция и переход на Joomla! 3.x
- ↳ Расширения для Joomla! 3.x
- ↳ Многоязычные веб-сайты на Joomla 3.x
- ↳ Joomla 2.5 - Задайте здесь свой вопрос по поддержке
- ↳ Общие вопросы/Новичок в Joomla! 2.5
- ↳ Установка Joomla! 2.5
- ↳ Расширения для Joomla! 2.5
- ↳ Русский язык Joomla! 2.5
- ↳ Serbian/Montenegrin Forum
- ↳ Tehnička pitanja
- ↳ Instalacija i početnička pitanja
- ↳ Šabloni
- ↳ Prevod i dokumentacija
- ↳ Ćaskanje
- ↳ Bezbednost
- ↳ Joomla! dodaci
- ↳ Pravna pitanja
- ↳ Arhiva
- ↳ Joomla! Događaji i Zajednica
- ↳ Izlog (spisak) sajtova radjenih u Joomla! CMS-u
- ↳ Profesionalne usluge
- ↳ Slovak Forum
- ↳ Spanish Forum
- ↳ Joomla! 5.x
- ↳ Joomla! 4.x
- ↳ Joomla! 3.x
- ↳ Migración y actualización a Joomla 3.x
- ↳ Versiones de Joomla! obsoletas
- ↳ Joomla! 2.5
- ↳ Joomla! 1.5
- ↳ Extensiones
- ↳ Plantillas (templates) y diseño
- ↳ Idioma y traducciones
- ↳ SEO para Joomla!
- ↳ Seguridad y rendimiento
- ↳ Productos de Código Abierto para Joomla!
- ↳ Servicios profesionales
- ↳ Salón de la comunidad Ñ
- ↳ Swedish Forum
- ↳ Meddelanden
- ↳ Forum Joomla! 5.x
- ↳ Forum Joomla! 4.x
- ↳ Forum Joomla! 3.x
- ↳ Allmänna frågor
- ↳ Användning och administration
- ↳ Installation, backup och säkerhet
- ↳ Komponenter, moduler och plugin
- ↳ Mallar (templates) och design
- ↳ Äldre versioner
- ↳ Forum Joomla! 1.0
- ↳ Allmänna frågor
- ↳ Användning och administration
- ↳ Installation, backup och säkerhet
- ↳ Komponenter, moduler och Mambots
- ↳ Mallar (templates) och design
- ↳ Forum Joomla! 1.7 / Joomla! 1.6
- ↳ Allmänna frågor
- ↳ Användning och administration
- ↳ Installation, backup och säkerhet
- ↳ Komponenter, moduler och plugin
- ↳ Mallar (templates) och design
- ↳ Forum Joomla! 1.5
- ↳ Allmänna frågor
- ↳ Användning och administration
- ↳ Installation, backup och säkerhet
- ↳ Komponenter, moduler och plugin
- ↳ Mallar (templates) och design
- ↳ Forum Joomla! 2.5
- ↳ Allmänna frågor
- ↳ Användning och administration
- ↳ Installation, backup och säkerhet
- ↳ Komponenter, moduler och plugin
- ↳ Mallar (templates) och design
- ↳ Översättning
- ↳ Webbplatser gjorda i Joomla
- ↳ Webbplatser J! 3.x
- ↳ Webbplatser J! 2.5
- ↳ Webbplatser Joomla! 1.7 / Joomla! 1.6
- ↳ Webbplatser J! 1.5
- ↳ Webbplatser J! 1.0
- ↳ Kommersiell hjälp önskas
- ↳ Diverse (off topic)
- ↳ Tamil Forum
- ↳ Thai Forum
- ↳ โชว์เว็บไซต์ของคุณที่สร้างด้วยจูมล่า
- ↳ เคล็ดลับการใช้งานส่วนต่างๆ เกี่ยวกับจ&#
- ↳ คอมโพเน้นท์ โมดูล ปลักอิน ต่างๆ ที่ติดตั
- ↳ อับเดดข่าวสารเกี่ยวกับจูมล่าลายไทย
- ↳ Turkish Forum
- ↳ Duyurular
- ↳ Dersler
- ↳ Genel Sorular
- ↳ Bileşen, Modül, Bot
- ↳ Eklenti Haberleri
- ↳ Temalar
- ↳ Vietnamese Forum
- ↳ Gặp gỡ và giao lưu
- ↳ Joomla Tiếng Việt
- ↳ Cài đặt - Cấu hình
- ↳ Thành phần mở rộng cho Joomla!
- ↳ Hỏi đáp Joomla! 5.x
- ↳ Hỏi đáp Joomla! 4.x
- ↳ Hỏi đáp Joomla! 3.x
- ↳ Hỏi đáp Joomla! 2.5
- ↳ Hỗ trợ kỹ thuật
- ↳ Bài viết cũ
- ↳ Thiết kế Template
- ↳ Joomla! 1.5
- ↳ Welsh Forum
- Other Forums
- ↳ Open Source Products for Joomla!
- ↳ The Lounge
- ↳ Forum Post Assistant (FPA)
- Joomla! Development Forums
- Joomla! Official Sites & Infrastructure
- ↳ docs.joomla.org - Feedback/Information
- ↳ extensions.joomla.org - Feedback/Information
- ↳ joomla.com - Feedback/Information
- ↳ Sites & Infrastructure - Feedback/Information
- ↳ Archived Boards - All boards closed
- ↳ Design and Accessibility - Archived
- ↳ Quality and Testing - Locked and Archived
- ↳ Joomla! 1.0.x_Q&T
- ↳ Q&T 1.0.x Resolved
- ↳ Known Issues
- ↳ Superseded Issues
- ↳ Archive
- ↳ Q&T 1.0.x Resolved - Archived
- ↳ Known Issues - Archive
- ↳ Superseded Issues - Archive
- ↳ Joomla! 3.x Bug Reporting
- ↳ Third Party Testing for Joomla! 1.5
- ↳ Q&T 1.5.x Resolved
- ↳ Joomla! 1.5 BETA
- ↳ Joomla! 1.5 BETA 2
- ↳ Reaction to the 'Letter to the community'
- ↳ Reaction to New Project Name
- ↳ Logo Competition
- ↳ Humor, Fun and Games
- ↳ Libraries
- ↳ patTemplate
- ↳ com_connector - Multi Joomla Bridge
- ↳ CiviCRM Support
- ↳ CiviCRM Installation Issues
- ↳ FAQ Archive
- ↳ FAQ Discussion Board
- ↳ 3rd Party Extensions FAQ
- ↳ FAQs not moved
- ↳ 3rd Party/Non Joomla! Security FAQ
- ↳ Joomla! Coding 101
- ↳ Joombie Tools of the Trade
- ↳ Joombie Coding Q/A
- ↳ Joombie Think Tank
- ↳ Joombie Developer Lab
- ↳ Joomla Forge - Archived
- ↳ Non-Profit Organizations and Joomla!
- ↳ Schools and Universities
- ↳ Bangsamoro Forum
- ↳ Joomla! 1.5 Template Contest
- ↳ SMF - Simplemachines.org Forum
- ↳ GPL Discussion
- ↳ Security Announcements - Old
- ↳ Tips & Tricks - Moving
- ↳ Submit Your Suggested Tips & Tricks to Docs.joomla.org now please.
- ↳ Google Summer of Code and GHOP
- ↳ Google Summer of Code 2008
- ↳ Proposed projects
- ↳ Student area
- ↳ Past Google Summer of Code Editions
- ↳ Google's Highly Open Participation Contest
- ↳ Documentation
- ↳ Suggestions, Modifications, and Corrections
- ↳ Archive
- ↳ 1.5 Archive
- ↳ Suggestions, Modifications & Corrections
- ↳ Submit
- ↳ Feedback and Suggestions
- ↳ Applications for participation in the Development Workgroup
- ↳ Development
- ↳ 1.5 Site Showcase - Archived
- ↳ 1.0 x Site Showcase - Archived.
- ↳ Feature Requests - White Papers - Archived
- ↳ Under Review - Archived
- ↳ Accepted - Archived
- ↳ Not Accepted - Archived
- ↳ Wishlists and Feature Requests - Archive
- ↳ Wishlist Archives - Archived
- ↳ Spanish Forum - Archive
- ↳ Papelera
- ↳ Tutoriales
- ↳ General
- ↳ Salón de la Joomlaesfera hispanohablante
- ↳ Danish Forum - Archive
- ↳ Diskussion af Meddelelser + Sikkerhedsmeddelelser + FAQ
- ↳ Shop.Joomla.org
- ↳ Joomla! 1.6 RC Support [closed]
- ↳ Joomla! 1.0 Coding
- ↳ Core Hacks and Patches
- ↳ Joomla! 2.5 Beta Support
- ↳ People.joomla.org - Feedback/Information
- ↳ Joomla! 1.5 Bug Reporting
- ↳ Joomla! 1.5 Coding
- ↳ Joomla! 3 Beta Support
- ↳ Trending Topics
- ↳ Help wanted in the community
- ↳ templates.joomla.org - Feedback/Information
- ↳ Certification
- ↳ Albanian Forum
- ↳ Azeri Forum
- ↳ Urdu Forum
- ↳ Basque Forum
- ↳ Itzulpenaren inguruan
- ↳ Laguntza teknikoa
- ↳ Belarusian Forum
- ↳ Maltese Forum
- ↳ Hungarian Forum
- ↳ Slovenian Forum
- ↳ Japanese Forum
- ↳ Khmer Forum
- ↳ ពិពណ៌ស្ថានបណ្ដាញជុំឡា
- ↳ ជុំឡាខ្មែរមូលដ្ឋានីយកម្ម
- ↳ Community Blog Discussions
- ↳ JoomlaCode.org
- ↳ Joomla! Marketing and PR Team
- ↳ resources.joomla.org - Feedback/Information
- ↳ Training.Joomla.org
- ↳ OpenSourceMatters.org
- ↳ magazine.joomla.org - Feedback/Information
- ↳ Site Showcase
- ↳ Joomla! 4 Related
- ↳ Joomla! Events
- ↳ Joomla! Ideas Forum
- ↳ Registered Joomla! User Groups
- ↳ Joomla! 2.5 Coding
- ↳ Joomla! 2.5 Bug Reporting
- ↳ User eXperience (UX)
- ↳ Joomla! Working Groups
- ↳ Translations