Varnish, NGINX & Joomla 5

[stormbyte]

Dear all,

I don't many threads regarding optimisation using Varnish.
From my side I developped a VCL only to cache static elements, a FastCGI Cache on NGINX to speedup page generation but that's all. I disabled JCH Optimize (even 9), deleted SpeedCache, and so on.

Using Varnish with static elements, a 2Gb FastCGI cache and dedicated server is giving better results than JCH or SpeedCache, and best of all is generating a new page content for each request.

But I know well there's a better approach, but I was unable to integrate it even spending hours with efforts on...
This is caching all pages generated from FastCGI and keeping them into Varnish cache.
The problem is clear: JOOMLA is generating a cookie even for visitor ... and that's the problem because each same static page is seen as a new request, not cached....

Guyz, anybody tried and success to cache HTML pages from FastCGI to Varnish?

What's the best approach (due to cookies?) ! Please share you toughts, ideads, code, whatever!
Thx


NB: I know before Joomla5 there was no such cookie. so not so complicated. I don't want to change the core Joomla, just to find a clear and professional approach to solve this link btw Varnish & Joomla 5

[stormbyte]

OK not sure this topic is attracting people

Nobody is using varnish AND joomla together Weird!

FastCGI cache is definitely great for accelerating page generation process, but for full HTML generated page it may be clearly interesting to avoid backend joomla request and throw directly pages from Varnish ...
At this time I'm caching pages from many other cools & systems BUT joomla and it's automatic cookie generation (even not authenticated) is a problem IMY. Any tips?

[pe7er]

Nobody is using varnish AND joomla together Weird!

I've used Varnish Cache in the past in a Joomla 3 website. We had some issues with:
- Logged in users and caching user data and displaying it to other users
- Emptying cache

However, these issues might have been caused by mistakes in our configuration.
Due to these problems, we decided to switch to Redis cache instead, which worked better in our case.

[stormbyte]

Hi Peter!
Thanks for your feedback. But Redis cache is only for session, I mean here Varnish is caching the full HTML webpage rendered by joomla!

But for sure for logged in users it's a pain, I think there's no real solution at all using Varnish for logged users it's better to use JCH or SpeedCache or whatever, Joomla side only.

But I'm searching for guest users ONLY (ready to cache same content for everybody!) but the visitor cookie is still generated by Joomla...

[pe7er]

Ok! If you want HTML webpage cache for guest users only,
why don't you just choose Joomla's core plugin System - Page Cache ?

[stormbyte]

When a user makes a request with 'System Page cache' , the request goes from:
client --> varnish (not cached) --> Nginx (FastCGI PHP Cache) --> Joomla/System Page Cache
then goes back to the user using the reverse side.

Rendering process is faster with "System Page" (using already cached elements from page,modules,etc) BUT from my own tests I removed JCH/SpeedCache/Page Cache and put a FastCGICache PHP Cache (everything in RAM virtual drive) in NGINX and rendering page is FASTER then being managed from Joomla. Weird, but real.

Page Cache is not activating a way to catch those elements inside the Varnish
They're present in cache but in the Joomla backend.

I want to find a way to deliver HTML from 1st tech element only: Varnish